‘Hazing on steroids’: Syracuse high school students surrender to police over incident

(SYRACUSE, N.Y.) -- A group of students from a high school in Syracuse, New York, surrendered to authorities on Wednesday for an alleged hazing incident described by the local district attorney as "incomprehensible."

All 11 implicated students surrendered themselves to police over the incident after being given a 48-hour deadline, the district attorney's office confirmed to Syracuse ABC affiliate WSYR.

"I cannot really adequately express to this community the level of stupidity and lack of judgement involved in this case," Onondaga County District Attorney Bill Fitzpatrick said during a press conference on Tuesday.

Fitzpatrick said he decided to prosecute charges against 11 students at Westhill High School who allegedly hazed a younger student on April 24.

In the evening hours of April 24, the students — most are members of the boys varsity lacrosse team — allegedly decided they would "haze or play some sort of prank on some of the younger members of the lacrosse team," Fitzpatrick said.

One victim told officials he thought he was going to have an "enjoyable evening with the upperclassman, go to a lacrosse game and finish the evening with something to eat at McDonald's," Fitzpatrick said.

But, on their way home from eating food, the driver of the car claimed he was lost, stopped in a remote part of the county, which is when "accomplices jumped out of the woods pretending to be kidnappers," Fitzpatrick said.

These accomplices, who were other students, were dressed in black and armed with "at least one handgun and at least one knife," Fitzpatrick said.

The victim had a pillowcase placed over his head, was tied up and placed in the trunk of the car, according to the DA.

"I've seen the video tape of what happened to this young man, it is not a rite of passage, it is not a trivial matter," Fitzpatrick said. "I find it incomprehensible that in this day and age that somebody thought they could have gotten away with something like this."

Investigators say there were four other potential victims, but they were able to flee the area.

Fitzpatrick, who described the incident as "hazing on steroids," had given the 11 suspects 48 hours to turn themselves into the sheriff's department.

The DA said Tuesday that if the suspects decided to surrender to police before Friday, their cases would either be handled through the family court system or would not fall under their criminal records.

He added that if the students refused to cooperate, they would be arrested, prosecuted as adults and charged with kidnapping in the second degree.

Fitzpatrick said the incident "goes way beyond hazing," likening it more to "criminal activity."

"If you want to welcome someone onto your team and toughen them up, maybe an extra hour of practice might be appropriate as opposed to taking someone at gunpoint, stuffing them in the back of a car and traumatizing them for the rest of their life," Fitzpatrick said.

Westhill Schools Superintendent Steven Dunham sent an email to families regarding the incident, saying the school made the "difficult decision to cancel the remainder of the Westhill High School varsity boys lacrosse season," even though the majority of those on the team were not involved in the alleged hazing.

"Some may argue that all student-athletes shouldn't be punished for the actions of a few. While I understand the perspective, we must address the culture of the program, and the most appropriate way to do that is with a reset," Dunham said.

Dunham said the school will address the behavior that "negatively impacts members of our school community promptly and appropriately according to our Code of Conduct."

Copyright © 2025, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.