National LGBTQ group urges New York prosecutor to pursue hate crime charges in killing of transgender man

(NEW YORK) -- The nation's largest LGBTQ advocacy organization is urging New York prosecutors to pursue hate crime charges against five suspects arrested in what authorities described as a prolonged "torture" killing of a transgender man.

The group, GLAAD, issued a statement calling on Ontario County District Attorney James Riffs to consider hate crime charges in the homicide of Sam Nordquist, whose body was found in a field in Benton, New York, in Yates County last week.

Riffs said the five suspects in Norquist's killing were arrested on suspicion of second-degree murder under the state's depraved indifference statute.

In a statement to ABC News on Wednesday morning, Ritts' office said that prosecutors filed a certification with the Hopewell Town Court "indicating that the Grand Jury of the County of Ontario voted at least one felony charge against all 5 defendants charged in connection with the death of Sam Nordquist."

The suspects arrested in the case were identified by New York State Police as Precious Arzuaga, 38, of Canandaigua, New York; Jennifer "Brooklyn" Quijano, 30, of Geneva, New York; Kyle Sage, 33, of Rochester, New York; Patrick Goodwin, 30, also of Canandaigua; and Emily Motyka, 19, of Lima, New York.

The statement from Ritts' office says the felony charge in the indictment against the suspects will be disclosed once it is filed in Ontario County Court.

"As this is an ongoing investigation and law prohibits us from disclosing any additional information at this time. This is the only update we can provide today," according to the statement.

A criminal complaint filed in the case alleged that the suspects sexually assaulted Nordquist with a "table leg and broomstick." The complaint further alleges that the suspects subjected Nordquist to "prolonged beatings by punching, kicking and striking [Nordquist] with numerous objects, including but not limited to sticks, dog toys, rope, bottles, belts, canes and wooden boards."

According to the complaint, the torture allegedly took place in room 22 at Patty's Lodge in Hopewell, New York, in Ontario County between Jan. 1 and Feb. 2.

In a joint statement released on Sunday, the state police and Ritts addressed whether investigators are pursuing hate crime charges against the suspects.

"At this time we have no indication that Sam's murder was a hate crime," the joint statement reads. "To help alleviate the understandable concern his murder could be a hate crime, we are disclosing that Sam and his assailants were known to each other, identified as LGBTQ+, and at least one of the defendants lived with Sam in the time period leading up to the instant offense."

Authorities said they released the information after getting "multiple inquiries from across our community, New York State and the entire nation."

In the statement, officials noted that under the New York State penal code, a hate crime is defined as an offense committed "in whole or in substantial part because of a belief or perception regarding the race, color, national origin, ancestry, gender, gender identity or expression, religion, religious practice, age, disability or sexual orientation of a person regardless of whether the belief or perception is correct."

In response, GLAAD released a statement Tuesday, saying, "While we are encouraged to see law enforcement act swiftly to investigate this horrific act, we caution investigators from ruling out hate crime charges."

"Anti-LGBTQ hate can be perpetuated by anyone, regardless of their relationship to the victim or their own gender identity or sexual orientation," GLAAD said.

Sarah Kate Ellis, president and CEO of GLAAD, added, "Our hearts are broken over the loss of Sam Nordquist."

"Sam was more than just a statistic -- he was a son, a brother, a friend, and and bright light in the lives of those who knew him," Ellis said in a statement. "His life was stolen from him after enduring unspeakable cruelty. We stand in solidarity with Sam's family, friends, and community as they demand justice. We refuse to let Sam's story fade into silence. We demand accountability, we demand justice, and we demand a world where transgender people are safe, respected, and able to live freely."

Nordquist's family filed a missing person report with the New York State Police on Feb. 9, after last hearing from Nordquist on Jan. 1, according to a missing-person flyer issued by the Missing People in America organization.

According to the flyer, Nordquist's family said he left Minnesota on Sept. 28, 2024, with a round-trip plane ticket to New York. The family, according to the flyer, alleged that Nordquist met a woman online who convinced him to visit her.

The family claimed Nordquist was planning to fly back to Minnesota within two weeks, but never boarded his return flight.

"I don't understand why someone would do that to another person," Kayla Nordquist, Sam's sister, told Saint Paul, Minnesota, ABC affiliate KSTP-TV. "Sam was amazing and would give the shirt off his back to anyone."

When asked at a news conference on Friday about the missing-person flyer, Capt. Kelly Swift, a New York State Police investigator, declined to comment.

Swift would not disclose details of the abuse, saying the investigation is in its early stages. However, she said, Nordquist was "subjected to repeated acts of violence and torture in a manner that ultimately led to his death."

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul said in a statement Sunday that she had directed the State Police to provide any support and resources to Ritts' office "as they continue their investigation, including into whether this was a hate crime." The statement further said that Hochul had directed the New York State Division of Human Rights Hate and Bias Prevention Unit to offer assistance and support "to all community members affected by this terrible act of violence," adding, "There must be justice for Sam Nordquist."

Hochul also said that she had instructed the New York State Office of Victim Services to offer support to Nordquist's family.

"The charges against these individuals are sickening and all New Yorkers should join together to condemn this horrific act," Hochul said in the statement. "We are praying for Sam Nordquist’s family, community and loved ones who are experiencing unimaginable grief."

New York Attorney General Letitia James also said in a statement, “This is beyond horrifying, and those responsible for this terrible act must be held accountable.”

Copyright © 2025, ABC Audio. All rights reserved.